|
2007 Annual Financial Reporting Document Review An all-in-one disclosure checklist
Deloitte has prepared a comprehensive assessment package to help management
and Directors determine whether or not their organizations’ financial statements
and other financial filings meet all of the continuous disclosure obligations.
Correspondingly, using these tools to analyze their financial filings may assist
users in fulfilling their due diligence responsibilities.
Download
the disclosure checklist from here.
Financial Statement Review Tool
This document is an assessment tool to assist users in the evaluation of
their company’s financial statement disclosures. The requirements as set out in
the CICA Handbook are included, along with an area for users to include
commentary specific to their company. This tool will allow users to specifically
address the impact of new accounting developments in their review of the
company’s public filings which include the financial statements. A series of
suggested questions which should be considered to ascertain whether the
standards were appropriately applied and whether all of the options/alternatives
available as well as the impact on the financial statements were considered
prior to the selection of an accounting treatment have been included.
|
Newly-adopted standards |
Comments |
|
What, if any, changes in accounting policies,
procedures or disclosures were required as a result of the
recommendations made by the Canadian Standard setters? |
|
|
What was the impact on the financial
statements of adopting the new recommendations? |
|
|
How has it been ensured that all of the
disclosure obligations relating to the recommendations have been
properly included in the notes to the financial statements? |
|
|
How was it decided whether to apply these
changes prospectively or retroactively and why? |
|
|
What
were the required changes to prior year’s financial statements as a
result of applying the change retroactively? |
|
|
How
did you ensure that the subsidiaries have properly adopted accounting
policy changes in their financial statements for consolidation purposes |
|
|
Alternatives Considered |
|
What
alternatives were considered and what was the impact of these
alternatives on the financial statement results and/or disclosure? |
|
|
Why
were the selected new accounting policies
adopted over the available alternatives? |
|
|
Impact |
|
|
Were
there any disagreements with the external auditors as to the appropriate
accounting treatment to be applied and if so, please describe them? |
|
|
Did
any of the required disclosure changes cause difficulty or discomfort
and why? |
|
|
Were
the required changes presented and discussed in past MD&A prior to the
date of implementation of the new recommendation? |
|
|
Why
do you believe this set of adopted accounting policies presents fairly
the company’s financial position/condition, results of operations and
cash flows? |
|
|
What
comments do the external auditors have in respect of the company’s
answers to the above questions? |
|
It is
not possible to anticipate all of the questions that may be required to ensure a
proper and full due-diligence for the accounting developments noted above.
Therefore, these questions provide the director with a starting point from which
a full and complete due-diligence of material issues may be conducted. The
questions to be asked always depend on the materiality of the impact on the
company’s public filings which are subject to board approval. Material items
often require more due-diligence by the board of directors. The questions above
have been proposed assuming that each issue is material to the shareholder. The
director must use judgment in determining to what extent each of the questions
should be raised.
Where
management believes that the adoption of the new accounting recommendations does
not result in fair presentation, management must present the alternative
presentation in the company’s management discussion and analysis (MD&A) such
that the CEO and CFO can properly certify the financial statements in conformity
with Multilateral Instrument 52-109. In these circumstances it is very important
that the board of directors conduct a thorough due diligence of the matter.
MD&A Evaluation
This
document is an assessment tool to assist users in the evaluation of their
company’s Management Discussion & Analysis (MD&A). The requirements as set out
in National Instrument 51-102 are included, along with an area for users to
include commentary specific to their company. This document may be used by both
the preparers of the MD&A as well as the Board members who must approve the
content. We encourage you to use this document as a guide to both ensure
compliance with statutory requirements as well as to provoke thought and
discussion on the disclosures included in your company’s MD&A.
|
Procedure |
Comments |
|
Read
the full document and ensure that: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ensure that the disclosure controls worked as designed and their
effectiveness is fairly described. |
|
|
Ensure that the internal control over financial reporting worked as
designed. |
|
|
Meet
with management and discuss any findings arising from your review. You
may want to hold discussions with your internal and external auditors as
well. |
|
|
Review with your external auditors their quality assessment of the MD&A. |
|
|
Document your review. |
|
AIF Evaluation
This
document is an assessment tool to assist users in the evaluation their company’s
Annual Information Form (AIF). The requirements as set out in National
Instrument 51-102 are included along with an area for users to include
commentary specific to their company. This document may be used by both the
preparers of the AIF as well as the Board members who must approve the content.
We encourage you to use this document as a guide to both ensure compliance with
statutory requirements as well as to provoke thought and discussion on the
disclosures included in your company’s AIF.
|
Procedure |
Comments |
|
Read
the full document and ensure that: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ensure that the disclosure controls worked as designed and their
effectiveness is fairly described. |
|
|
Ensure that the internal control over financial reporting worked as
designed. |
|
|
Meet
with management and discuss any findings arising from your review. You
may want to hold discussions with your internal and external auditors as
well. |
|
|
Review with your external auditors their quality assessment of the MD&A. |
|
|
Document your review. |
|
Next Steps
Now that you
have completed the analysis of your organization’s 2007 annual documents listed
below are some suggested next steps in performing your due diligence:
|
Evaluate your results |
Comments |
|
Discuss your findings with the other audit committee members, management
and your external auditors. |
|
|
Establish your action plan |
|
Identify what needs to be done to ensure the annual documents are
compliant, relevant and transparent. |
|
|
Review with your external auditors their GAAP quality assessment of the
financial statements. |
|
|
Inquire as to the processes put in place to enable the CEO and CFO to
fulfill their certification obligations for 2007. |
|
|
Inquire as to the plans in place which will allow the CEO and CFO to
continue to fulfill their certification requirements as these
requirements increase to cover the evaluation of internal control over
financial reporting during 2008. |
|
|
Ensure the audit committee minutes document your financial statement and
other financial filings review process. |
|
|
Ensure you understand the external auditor’s summary of unadjusted
misstatements – both quantitative and disclosure misstatements. |
|
Keep current
with the new accounting and regulatory pronouncements affecting your financial
reporting.
Subscribe to the
various Deloitte periodicals to stay abreast of accounting
and regulatory developments.
Conclusion
Organizations
cannot afford to underestimate the impact of the continuous disclosure
obligations.
Deloitte’s
professionals offer a range of solutions that can be customized to meet your
organization's specific compliance needs.
Subject to
appropriate independence safeguards and service pre-approval, Deloitte can
assist you to ensure that that your disclosures are complete, as well as helping
in the implementation of governance best practices.
|